Oh definitely. The poster also pointed out the underlying contradictions of:
1. Draco being *forced* to Crutio Rowle. What happened to needing to really *mean* it?
2. Hermione memory charming the DEs. So how did Rowle even remember that they'd been tracing Potter then?
2. Doholov having only been petrified, not stunned, while the trio discussed what they were going to do next in front of him. Although if the memory charm had taken that would have been the very first thing he would have known since they discussed it *after* the charm was implied.
And then someone in the discussion pointed out that not only does Rowling not read her own work after it's published, she doesn't even read back two paragraphs of her own drafts once she writes it.
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: 2008-08-30 09:22 pm (UTC)1. Draco being *forced* to Crutio Rowle. What happened to needing to really *mean* it?
2. Hermione memory charming the DEs. So how did Rowle even remember that they'd been tracing Potter then?
2. Doholov having only been petrified, not stunned, while the trio discussed what they were going to do next in front of him. Although if the memory charm had taken that would have been the very first thing he would have known since they discussed it *after* the charm was implied.
And then someone in the discussion pointed out that not only does Rowling not read her own work after it's published, she doesn't even read back two paragraphs of her own drafts once she writes it.