The fan's perspective on Dark magic...

[sweettalkeress.livejournal.com]

So, elsewhere on the 'net, I came across someone tearing apart The Draco Trilogy, and this person had something very interesting to say about Dark magic:

When you use Dark Magic, it's because you want someone to die, or feel terrible pain, or bend unquestioningly to your will; you want that for its own sake, and not necessarily to accomplish anything. Dark Magic has nothing to do with whether or not a spell causes pain, just the wizard casting it.

This came from a fan of the series, of course, but without meaning to it in essence confirms what we've been saying all along about the way morality and Dark magic work in this series--it's not the spells a wizard uses that are Dark or otherwise, it's whether the wizard themselves is good or evil. If the wizard using a spell is "evil," then no matter what they do it will be evil and Dark. If the wizard using a spell is "good," then no matter what they do it will be good and not-Dark.

Comments

[aikaterini.livejournal.com]

/If the wizard using a spell is "evil," then no matter what they do it will be evil and Dark. If the wizard using a spell is "good," then no matter what they do it will be good and not-Dark./

Which is why Harry doesn’t face any consequences for using a Cruciatus Curse, but Draco is sliced open after trying to use one. And why Snape’s purported immersion into the Dark Arts is justification for the Marauders bullying him.

Just out of curiosity, could you give me a link to the Draco Trilogy sporking? Who was the sporker?

[sweettalkeress.livejournal.com]

It's being sporked by one of the newbies who joined within the past month or so. The table of contents is at the following address:

http://das-sporking.livejournal.com/644535.html

However it's open to members only (of course, if you are a member you've got nothing to worry about).

I've tried reading through the sporking but it's just so boring. There's almost no variation in the way the text looks so the entire thing feels like a suffocating wall of text (even though it's not), and it seems like she spends too much time on grammar mistakes rather than the actual content of the work.

[josephinestone.livejournal.com]

I should have read the other comments.

Yeah, it's blocked for me or I would have noticed it, because I think I follow this community.