More on Albus Dumbledore_

[mary-j-59.livejournal.com]

Hi, everyone. This will be quite short, but something sunnyskywalker said in a previous discussion rang bells with me. What if these books aren't quite what we think they are?


I am thinking of an interview with Rowling some years back, when she answered a question about her faith with words to this effect: "I struggle to keep believing". If anyone has the exact quote, I'd be grateful!

Because, you see, that is quite moving to me. It is hard to keep believing in God when you witness truly evil things happening to people you love. At least, you can't go on believing, like a child, in the wise old man with a beard who will make everything all right. That's so obviously not what God is.*

But, in these books, we have a wise old man with a beard. And he is very, very imperfect. Rowling's depiction of Dumbledore does, indeed, seem like an indictment of sorts.

But Dumbledore is obviously not God. He is just the headmaster of a wizarding school. Harry, despite some of the imagery surrounding him, is just as obviously not Jesus. Who is he? As I said on my blog some time back, he is an everyman character - specifically, he's Percival, the fool.

And - I think there is some kind of sense there, lurking deep down. I can't quite put my finger on it, but sometimes I think it's there.

Because, if there is a Christ figure at all in these books (but I don't think there is), that is definitely Severus Snape, in spite of his obvious imperfections. If Harry is Percival, Snape is the Fisher King; the wounded king of a wounded land. And what heals the Fisher King? Compassion and curiosity. Percival is supposed to ask a question. We all know that Harry never does that, don't we?

But, if Snape is the Fisher King and Harry Percival, who on earth is Dumbledore? Because he's not God. Not consciously, anyway. And - it's interesting that one of his names is Percival. What I'm getting at is that I sometimes think that the 'lost boys' of Hogwarts are all facets of him.

Rowling is playing with some very powerful archetypes in these stories, I think, and that's why we are still struggling to find meaning in them.

My two cents!

* As those who know me know, I'm a devout Catholic. To me, God is nothing like Dumbledore.

Comments

[sunnyskywalker]

If the series actually followed things to logical conclusions, as soon as Voldemort was dead, the goblins would take advantage of the chaos from the growing population of rogue Dementors to rebel again (possibly using getting the sword back as a rallying point).

Well, Draco does like to perform - maybe he wrote a best selling tell-all about growing up in a Death Eater household, his struggle to overcome everything he's been taught once he realizes he doesn't have the stomach for all this killing etc., and his time as near-prisoner in his own house with the Dark Lord and Aunt Bellatrix trying not to participate or get killed. With poetry.

[majorjune.livejournal.com]

Well, Draco does like to perform - maybe he wrote a best selling tell-all about growing up in a Death Eater household

I feel another poll coming on....

;-)

[oryx_leucoryx]

Either he's an actor (or other kind of performer) or he's in the furniture business, selling and repairing cabinets.

[majorjune.livejournal.com]

Yes, I definitely feel another poll coming on...

;-)

WWDD? What Would Draco Do? (yet another poll)

[majorjune.livejournal.com]

Yep, I couldn't resist!

Vote here:

http://majorjune.livejournal.com/33111.html

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

What happened to all the Dementors, anyways? I don't remember any mention of them after Voldemort died.