Jumping Ship from the Lily's Pad

[oneandthetruth.livejournal.com]

On Saturday night I was catching up on reading DTCL and came across a post from terri_testing about why so few people claim James and Lily as friends. (posted 8/6/12, in reply to “Lupin’s ‘Resignation’,” by danajsparks) Part of it reads: 

What did happen to those witch friends Lily had in fifth year, the ones who couldn't understand why she even talked to Severus, the ones she sat and chatted with after the DADA OWL? Did their jealousy over the Mudblood scooping the Head Girl position (and the most eligible Pureblood bachelor) separate them? Were they naturally driven apart by diverging life paths caused by Lily's extremely early settling into marriage and motherhood while her friends all pursued careers....? 

Or there's always the solution I proposed in my abusive!James fic "Liberacorpus," that James had taken the precaution of sleeping his way through all of Lily's friends, so as to alienate them from her.... 

This got me to thinking: Maybe Lily’s friends were alienated, not by her good fortune or by James, but by Lily herself. I see two possibilities, both of which reflect badly on her and which are not mutually exclusive:

1) It’s certainly possible Lily’s friends were jealous because she got to be Head Girl and caught Big Wizard on Campus James. But under normal circumstances, friends get over such things. 

At least, they would have unless Lily rubbed their faces in her triumphs. If she bragged about how lucky she was, or how her success was proof of her greatness, particularly since she was a latecomer to the wizarding world, that would alienate anyone who wasn’t a complete doormat.

Of course, there is no proof Lily did that. But this kind of behavior accords with the assertion some people, most notably marionros, have made about Lily’s being a narcissist. Narcissists love to brag about themselves anyway (think Dumbledore in King’s Cross), and a triumphant narcissist would be worse than normal.

Such boasting is also compatible with the behaviors we see from Lily that indicate she had a poor character. For example, she was somewhat contemptuous and superior towards Severus, such as when she ordered him around, dismissed his feelings and concerns, or automatically took other people’s versions of events over his. 

She also exhibited a sadistic streak by using her magic to scare and torment Petunia. This is the moral equivalent of having your friends hold somebody while you punch them, or shoving over someone in a wheelchair, then laughing when they can’t get up.

No wonder she walked off and left her “best friend” to be attacked. She was doing the same thing outside of school herself, and to her own sister, who could not fight back. Which brings me to my next point. 

2) The other possibility for why Lily’s friendships ended may impart to her schoolmates a level of perspicacity they didn’t possess, but it’s an interesting idea anyway.

Lily may have bragged to or joked with her friends about using her magic to torment Petunia. I would never want to be friends with a person who was debased enough to attack her own family for entertainment.  

Regarding Severus, while Lily’s friends were no doubt happy to see her dump the greasy Slytherin, they may not have liked the way she did it. Initially, they just would have been happy he was gone, but over time, they may have become uncomfortable with her actions.

This was a boy Lily had known for six years, since she was nine. Her friends may have known she’d told Severus they were “best friends.” She had refused to break off their friendship for years, despite pressure from her House to dump him.

Then one day, he slipped up and insulted her while under extreme stress. And that was it. She literally turned her back on him and left him while he was helpless, to be assaulted by a ruthless gang of thugs. 

Severus didn’t just apologize for insulting her. He actually groveled to her, begging her forgiveness, risking his safety in the process. (Every time I think about this scene, I hear the Temptations singing, “Ain’t Too Proud to Beg.”) Yet she refused to even accept his apology, let alone have anything to do with him again.

If Lily was a prefect, her behavior was even worse. Regardless of her feelings for the victim, it was her duty to protect someone from being assaulted, especially by a group of attackers. She failed to do the job she’d been chosen for, to live up the obligation she’d accepted. This makes her nothing but a prettier, spunkier version of Remus the Spineless because they both allowed their personal feelings to prevent them from doing their duty.

I can’t help comparing Lily and Remus as prefects with the black American soldiers who served in World War II. These men fought and died for their country, even though they had been the victims of vicious racism at home and knew they would be again once the war was over. They realized many of the people they were fighting for were disgusting bigots who didn’t consider them fully human. They usually weren’t even allowed to serve in the same units as white soldiers. Many of them were only a few years older than Lily and Remus. Yet despite all that, they put their sense of duty ahead of their personal feelings and risked their lives for all Americans, regardless of how loathsome many individuals were. That is why they are now considered groundbreaking heroes. 

Imagine having Lily as a comrade in the Order. You will go into battle with her and trust her with your life. You’ll expect her to have your back, no matter what. 

What if you say or do something wrong while under pressure? How do you know that, when you need her the most, she won’t turn her back on you, too, and leave you at the mercy of your enemies? If she could do that to someone she’d been friends with almost half her life, why wouldn’t she do it to you as well?

Would you trust someone like that in battle?

I wouldn’t. 

  

Comments

[sunnyskywalker]

That's one of the sticking points for me with Lily's character. I agree with aasaylva that Sev's use of the slur could be a reasonable reason to end the friendship - even if she does believe he's sorry, and used it as a word that can be used as an insult against people like her (rather than meaning that he thought it described people like her accurately) to take Oryx's distinction - that combined with the fact that his friends are supposedly known to be anti-Muggleborn generally would make it harder to trust him as a friend. Depending on the exact circumstances (just how bad have Sev's friends been? would he be in danger if he stood up to them?), maybe they could work it out, maybe not, but I wouldn't particularly hold it against her, even if she didn't handle it especially well, because that is something I'll cut immature, emotional teenagers a break for.

But. She sees her friend - even if they're on the rocks, he's still been her best friend for years - being tormented, and her response is not to give James a warning and then try to disarm him and/or call for backup if she needs it, but to stand there and flirt-fight with him? At best, it looks like she doesn't value Sev's well-being that highly. And after watching James attack Sev and others unprovoked - starting him being a snob and jackass on the train - for years, she finds James at all attractive? Most people I know would have an instinctively aversive reaction toward someone like that, even if they believed he had done one single good thing once. I think this would be a valid reason for Sev to want to stop being friends with Lily.

So given that, it seems a lot more like Lily isn't especially bothered by bullying and cruelty as such, unless it's directed at her or someone she values that day. Or is committed by someone she doesn't like. Or it looks like she supports arbitrary bullying of people who don't "deserve" it, because I don't think that fits with her image of herself as one of the good people who doesn't do that sort of thing. And that puts her dumping Sev and hooking up with James a year later in a worse light.

I doubt that her friends would be particularly bothered if she did talk about turning Petunia's teacup into a rat etc., because that doesn't seem like something most witches and wizards would see as anything but a hilarious prank. And they probably thought Sev deserved whatever he got. But if she had a habit of abandoning friends who had offended her to unpleasant situations, or just dropping them, they might clue in that it wasn't just about leaving one slimy Slytherin to a richly-deserved fate, but something about Lily's character which made being friends with her more difficult. Especially if it were out of proportion to the offenses. That might have led to a cooling of friendships, during or after their school years.

It's also entirely possible that while James wasn't still hexing everyone into oblivion, he was still an ass, and Lily wouldn't listen if her friends complained about this and came up with all sorts of reasons why they were wrong or oversensitive or started it. That would get old, fast.

Another possibility is that Lily and James were a really annoying couple, one of the kind who suddenly never, ever have time for you after they get together. It would be easy enough for her friends go go, "Fine, you're too busy to hang out now that you're with Jamesie-pooh? We'll just have girls' night without you, then."

[oryx_leucoryx]

But if she had a habit of abandoning friends who had offended her to unpleasant situations, or just dropping them, they might clue in that it wasn't just about leaving one slimy Slytherin to a richly-deserved fate, but something about Lily's character which made being friends with her more difficult.

Continuing this line of thought, it may have been Lily who abandoned her friends one by one. Or perhaps after she became James' girlfriend there were situations where James' 3 friends complained about Lily's 2-3 friends and at some moment of conflicting loyalties she chose James' friends.

[sionna-raven.livejournal.com]

Or perhaps after she became James' girlfriend there were situations where James' 3 friends complained about Lily's 2-3 friends and at some moment of conflicting loyalties she chose James' friends.

They don't need to complain or be openly unfriendly. It's an awkward situation to bring another girl into this 'exclusive' boys club. They are contend with each others company. Lily is accepted as James' girlfriend.
It gets worse, if any of her friends was interested in Lupin or Sirius and hoped Lily could 'help'. Lupin would be utterly embarrassed and I don't even want to imagine how Sirius would react to the slightest hint of attempted match-making.

[hwyla.livejournal.com]

I'm a bit late jumping in here - however, I think there is also the possibility that her girlfriends abandoned her for her own nasty habits. We see repeatedly that when Lily feels she has been attacked she can get quite nasty and go for the spot that hurts the most.

We watch her do so to Petunia while waiting for the Hogwarts Express - telling her she knows about Petunia's letter to Dumbledore. And we see that repeated in SWM after Snape insults her with Mudblood - she responds with not just 'Snivelous' but also the comment about his 'greyed' undershorts (in other words about his poverty, she knows darn well they are old because he can't afford better)

I therefore wouldn't be in the least bit surprised if she didn't end up alienating her other friends at some point as well.

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

I'm even later here, but I really can't understand why Lily is seen as a likeable character by the fanbase. The fact that she seems to both enjoy being a bully and being around other bullies makes me lose all sympathy for her. Especially her cruelty to Petunia. Petunia may not be a very nice person as an adult, but I can sure see why she would have such hatred for anything connected to her narcissistic monster of a sister.

[oneandthetruth.livejournal.com]

Before I read these books, I deliberately ignored everything about them as much as possible--media reports, online fora, anything. To this day, I've never seen the movies. I waited until the entire series had been finished for almost 2 years before I read it. I did all that so I could come to the books with the most open-minded and unprejudiced attitude possible.

I started out having neutral feelings for Lily, but the more and closer I look at her, the worse she looks. I can't help that. That's just what's on the page. She and her ilk behave just as badly as the "bad" characters, such as Snape and Petunia, but we're supposed to look at the "good" characters' jerkiness and pretend it's not really jerkiness because "good" characters are doing it. Judging behavior is all purely arbitrary, based on the author's personal preferences, and the readers are supposed to mindlessly go along with that double standard just because the author says so. "Because I say so" may work with toddlers, but it shouldn't work with adults.

What's so sad about this fandom is that it does work with so many fans. We've all seen canon whores wailing, for example, "The Death Eaters are so as bad as Nazis! It says so right in the books!"

Who are you gonna believe, JKR or your lying eyes? The answer to that question is what separates the fans who are mental and emotional adults from the ones, no matter their age, who are still mental and emotional children.

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

What's so sad about this fandom is that it does work with so many fans. We've all seen canon whores wailing, for example, "The Death Eaters are so as bad as Nazis! It says so right in the books!"

What bothers me more is when the people who are doing this really ought to know better. I know quite a few very intelligent people, some of whom actually have a background in literature, who nonetheless tend to believe everything JKR says, even if it directly contradicts what's actually written in the books. Of course, I can't be too hard on them, as I was kind of like that myself a few years ago. The difference is that I finally stopped ignoring the things about the series that had always bugged me a little, rather than blithely accepting them as part of JKR's perfect master plan.

[josephinestone.livejournal.com]

What's so sad about this fandom is that it does work with so many fans. We've all seen canon whores wailing, for example, "The Death Eaters are so as bad as Nazis! It says so right in the books!"

I know these is really old (I just saw your latest post and wanted to start from the beginning of your posts), but this mentality has always bothered me. Not just with Harry Potter fans, but every time I run into in when talking about the Holocaust. People talking about Nazis as though they weren't people. It just bothers me. I don't understand it. As much as it is talked about and most people still don't even know what a Nazi even was.

They forget (or just don't get?) that when you are under a dictatorship, you don't get to choose your political party anymore.

ETA: Judging behavior is all purely arbitrary, based on the author's personal preferences, and the readers are supposed to mindlessly go along with that double standard just because the author says so.

This has always bothered me, but I'm normally attacked (or just have people try to explain it all away as children's books) when I say anything about it. I do love the series, but it isn't flawless.

[for-diddled.livejournal.com]

Preconceptions count, I suppose. Before we see Lily we spend four and a half books reading about how perfect and wonderful she is, so people are predisposed towards interpreting her actions in the most positive light possible.

[oryx_leucoryx]

Actually the only things we heard about Lily up to the point of SWM were: Hagrid telling how wonderful she and James were in PS, Albus saying she died to protect her son and we heard the dementors' inspired memory of the last few minutes of her life. Hagrid was wrong about James, why wouldn't he be wrong about Lily? Or is it because Severus said bad things about James and turned out to be right, but didn't say anything about Lily - so people still had hope for her?

(There was a bit in the POA movie from 'Remus' that inspired much of fandom's view of Lily, I think.)

[for-diddled.livejournal.com]

Hmm, yes, good point. I suppose it might be a combination of:

1.) We do get some less favourable information about James, even before SWM. Severus, for example, often complains about his behaviour in school, and although we're clearly meant to see Snape as mean and bitter, we at least know that some people see/saw James more negatively than Hagrid did. And again in POA, Sirius recounts his youthful escapades with James and the other Marauders; even though Sirius clearly still sees them as harmless youthful hijinx, they're actually pretty dangerous (going out with Lupin even after those near misses with Hogsmeade inhabitants? Seriously?), and point at an unattractively reckless, self-centred streak in James' personality. With Lily, the only things we hear are as you say that she was totally wonderful and laid down her life for Harry, so the portrayal of her is already more positive in the early books.

2.) It isn't really clear until "The Prince's Tale" that Snape and Lily were close friends. Her actions in SWM would be more understandable if she and Severus didn't really know each other, or if they had an antagonistic relationship like most other Gryffindors and Slytherins seem to.

3.) Snape and Petunia are both nasty people, and as we all know, people's personalities don't change at all over the course of their lifetimes, and definitely aren't affected by the way they were treated as children. Clearly therefore those two must have been equally nasty when they were kids, and therefore we ought to recognise Lily's treatment of them as the just and righteous punishment it clearly was.

[oryx_leucoryx]

With Lily, the only things we hear are as you say that she was totally wonderful and laid down her life for Harry, so the portrayal of her is already more positive in the early books.

Funny that the only character to actually provide the 'Lily was totally wonderful' aspect in canon before SWM is Hagrid, whose views we should have learned to suspect by then (see 'there's not a single witch or wizard who went bad who wasn't in Slytherin'). And he praises both James and Lily in one breath, never saying anything unique to distinguish their qualities.

And after SWM there was Horace, but again, we see how untrustworthy his opinion is in the very same book he is introduced.

[seductivedark.livejournal.com]

Snape and Petunia are both nasty people...

And, Petunia had nothing but bad things to say about Harry's parents. She spoke against Lily. Since we're not supposed to like Petunia, we're actually encouraged to think of Lily as being the opposite of what Petunia says. Same with Snape's version of James.

[oneandthetruth.livejournal.com]

She sees her friend - even if they're on the rocks, he's still been her best friend for years - being tormented, and her response is not to give James a warning and then try to disarm him and/or call for backup if she needs it, but to stand there and flirt-fight with him?

If she had cared about Severus, or even about doing her duty, she would have: (1) ordered James and Sirius to leave Severus alone. (2) If they didn't comply, Stupefy or Body-bind them and take their wands. (3) undone their spells and checked to see if Severus was all right. (4) Levitated James and Sirius into the castle, either alone or with help, so they could be punished.

So given that, it seems a lot more like Lily isn't especially bothered by bullying and cruelty as such, unless it's directed at her or someone she values that day. Or is committed by someone she doesn't like. Or it looks like she supports arbitrary bullying of people who don't "deserve" it, because I don't think that fits with her image of herself as one of the good people who doesn't do that sort of thing.

Gasp! You're not suggesting she's fickle or shallow, are you? ;-)

I doubt that her friends would be particularly bothered if she did talk about turning Petunia's teacup into a rat etc., because that doesn't seem like something most witches and wizards would see as anything but a hilarious prank.

If you're talking about most magical on non-magical violence, I would agree with you. The reason I specified family is because many people consider it worse to abuse your family than people not related to you. So they might think it's not OK to torment your own sister, but it is OK to do the same to some random stranger.

Another possibility is that Lily and James were a really annoying couple

Oh, I can easily see that. Heck, they're annoying all by themselves; put them together and the irritation factor goes up exponentially.

[sunnyskywalker]

Well, given how clueless wizards are about psychological trauma, I can't see turning teacups into rats being a big deal to them even if it is your sister's teacup. Transfiguring her into a rat, sure, but just changing an object in front of her for a bit of a scare? Nah. It has no physical effect, and there's no drunken mob threatening physical violence later, so what's the harm?

I think I could get over a Lily who was merely fickle or shallow. That would just be disappointing. But fickleness or shallowness as a motivation to passively support four-on-one waterboarding? That's just horrifying.

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

Of course, if Petunia had found some way to defend herself, such as pulling a knife on her or something, it would mean that she's a terrible, terrible person who just can't appreciate Lily's awesomeness.

I swear, I think the thing that I hate the most about this series is that the author refuses to let her readers decide who the good and bad guys are. She plays favorites in a way pretty similar to Petunia and Dudley, actually.

[oneandthetruth.livejournal.com]

Of course, if Petunia had found some way to defend herself, such as pulling a knife on her or something, it would mean that she's a terrible, terrible person who just can't appreciate Lily's awesomeness.

Oh, I love that idea! It's too bad they have such strict gun laws in the UK (for dramatic purposes, of course, not RL purposes). I can just imagine Petunia pulling out a 9 MM and snarling, "Hex this, MF!" Blam, blam, blam, blam! There goes Lily and Harry.

Of course, Severus would probably come after Petunia then, and get killed, too. But at least he wouldn't be wasting his life pining after somebody who didn't care about him.

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

Am I a terrible person that this made me laugh hysterically?

At the very least, it would teach the WW not to underestimate firearms as much as they seem to.

[oneandthetruth.livejournal.com]

No, it just means you're terribly disgusted with the illogic and one-sidedness of these books. As for guns, you can bet American magicals don't dismiss guns the way British magicals do. Not with all those news reports of people being shot, either accidentally or on purpose.

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

You know, this is why I don't buy Hagrid's explanation of why the WW has to be kept a secret from Muggles. A more likely reason I can think of is fear. Sure, wizards can wave their wands around and make cool stuff happen, but as far as raw, wholesale slaughter, the Muggles have them beat by far. Not only is their warfare technology far superior, but the sheer numbers alone ought to make wizards worry. When secrecy is the only thing that's keeping you from potentially being slaughtered or turned into a military experiment, I can see wizards wanting to be cut off from the rest of the world. What I can't see, though, is this haughty, half-*ssed attempt at concealment. "Now, remember, we don't want these stupid and inferior Muggles catching onto us, but it's OK to go around speaking openly about magic and dressing in the most conspicuous way possible, tehe!"

[majorjune.livejournal.com]

Not only is their warfare technology far superior, but the sheer numbers alone ought to make wizards worry. When secrecy is the only thing that's keeping you from potentially being slaughtered or turned into a military experiment, I can see wizards wanting to be cut off from the rest of the world. What I can't see, though, is this haughty, half-*ssed attempt at concealment. "Now, remember, we don't want these stupid and inferior Muggles catching onto us, but it's OK to go around speaking openly about magic and dressing in the most conspicuous way possible, tehe!"

And much is made regarding how they can use spells to hide themselves and their buildings from the prying eyes of nonmagikal folk, Hogwarts and Hogsmeade especially. But I doubt that such spells would effect spy satellites, nor protect them from a smart bomb if nonmagikals ever so desired to attack magikal folk.

[charlottehywd.livejournal.com]

Well, perhaps it's just that they are too arrogant to bother researching non-magical weaponry and realize how dangerous their situation is. They had better hope that they never do anything to make the non-magical government regard them as a threat.

[oneandthetruth.livejournal.com]

That reminds me of a great line I saw in a fanfic recently. Snape was trying to give Harry a very simple explanation of genetics, but Harry didn't understand it. Snape said, "Don't feel bad. I went to Hogwarts instead of a real school, too."

[lynn-waterfall.livejournal.com]

What was the story -- do you have a link? Sounds like an interesting one!

[majorjune.livejournal.com]

They had better hope that they never do anything to make the non-magical government regard them as a threat.

The thing is, they needn't even be the direct target but collateral damage...

During the Cold War, if the USSR and USA started a nuclear war London would surely have been one of the USSR's targets...and I doubt all the camoflaging spells in the world would have saved the Ministry of Magic or St. Mungo's from the effects of a Russian nuclear ICBM...