HBP Chapter Three
Mar. 31st, 2006 11:55 am![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
sistermagpie.livejournal.com posting in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
deathtocapslock*This is the chapter where Dumbledore’s a total asshole, isn’t it? ::sigh::
*Harry snores! And he sleeps with his mouth open! His room’s a mess! He’s so human and flawed—get it?
*Btw, I’m just going to assume that although he’s waiting for Dumbledore to pick him up he hasn’t showered in four days.
*If anybody wants to have a quick argument about “fug” and whether it’s a typo or a real word, and whether if it’s a real word it’s the right word to use here, here’s your time. Harry’s sleeping. He won’t mind.
*I know I already mentioned him being a slob but…apple cores? That’s gross. I’ll bet there’s owl droppings all over everything too.
*So the prophecy is fabled? People didn’t know about it before? Why not, since Dumbledore helpfully had it officially placed in the MoM? Isn’t this the type of thing everyone is supposed to find out about, like Harry and the Philosopher’s Stone?
*Some are going so far as to call Harry Potter “The Chosen One” because being wizards we don’t know that’s Keanu Reeves. And that it’s a really bad cliché.
*Scrimgeor has a “ravaged face.” This is a world where pretty much everything can be cured, yet we’ve got all these Gryffindor men walking around with scarred faces. Don’t tell me that’s not intentional.
*So…does Augusta Longbottom think Neville is a friend of Harry’s because Neville pathetically talks about him all the time, or is she, like everyone else, just desperate to drop Harry’s name?
*The Ministry has come up with tons of new security for Hogwarts. They do not know a man is coming to destroy their petty plans for protection. His house is Slytherin and his name is Señor Draco.
*Dear Harry, if it is convenient to you… Oh man, Albus is laying it on thick. Like he cares if it’s convenient to anyone.
*Harry had not packed. And before you criticize him at all he didn’t pack because he’s an orphan and doesn’t trust anyone to really care about him or for anything to work out well ever. There. Bet you feel badly now for suggesting he might have packed.
*He’s also completely forgotten to warn the Dursleys. Also because he’s an orphan and...well, because it’ll be funnier if the Dursleys get to gape when Albus shows up.
*Harry notes that Vernon can tell Dumbledore is a man difficult to bully. Somehow he manages to do this without considering that this is because Dumbledore is a bigger bully.
*And so begins Dumbledore’s plan of “Bait the Muggles to show what a great guy I really am to Harry so maybe he forgets that I didn’t care how the Muggles treated him until I needed him.”
*Btw, the Dursleys are all still ugly. So I guess they’re still bad people.
*Sadly, I find myself getting my hopes up that the Dursleys will get a chance to show Harry how little they care that Dumbledore has died next year, but presumably Ron and Hermione will descend on their house and move in to bully them for weeks in his place. This will go over with all the readers who haven’t figured out they themselves are Muggles yet.
*The glasses knocking against the Dursleys heads makes me so angry, and makes Dumbledore such a dick, it makes me want to climb into the book and tell him off. And push Ginny out a window. Even though she hasn’t appeared yet.
*Harry couldn’t suppress the suspicion that Dumbledore is enjoying himself with his Muggle-baiting. Well, of course he is. Here he has to be a good liberal all the time and pretend to think well of Muggles. You can imagine his joy when he finds a family of Muggles who have annoyed him so he can magically bully them while telling himself it’s not anything like Death Eaters doing it. Like the Weasleys, Dumbledore has earned himself some righteous Muggle-baiting through all his lip service to Muggle Protection.
*Dumbledore says Sirius’ will was discovered. Could that sound more fake? How long did it take you to write that will before you discovered it, Big D? And he left Harry everything, you say?
*More gold for Harry—phew! The world needs more heirs to fortunes who actually deserve it.
*By the way, Lupin’s been reduced to donating pints of blood for money, but I’m sure he’d want Sirius’ money to go to you. Rich Pureblood money should stay in the family.
*Vernon reminds us how awful he is by looking greedy at the idea of Harry being left a house. Harry, naturally, accepts his second fortune in gold with dignity by not caring at all. Unlike, say, crass, Muggle ME, who would be wondering if I could pay off my student loans. This is why money should stay with money.
*Now that Sirius is dead, Harry is free to love him the way he knows best, by making wild, violent gestures in the direction of his enemies. When he was alive he had to, like, speak to him and stuff and he didn’t care for that.
*"It would have been better manners to drink it, you know." Fuck you Dumbledore. Seriously. Fuck you with your own dead black hand. *pushes Ginny out the window because she would think this was hilarious.*
*Yay! Kreacher’s back!
*Petunia shrieks. Nothing this filthy has entered her house in living memory. Um, I beg to differ. Harry lives right upstairs.
*So if Sirius hadn’t left a will Kreacher would have gone to Bellatrix? That was pretty stupid on the Order’s part, wasn’t it? Or is Dumbledore lying because he wants Harry to have Kreacher for some reason? When in doubt, it’s usually best to assume DD is lying.
*So. Harry’s a slave-owner now. I’m sure Hermione will have something to say about that. After two books of non-stop SPEW it’s sure to just come to a head in this book. Funny how it doesn’t enter Harry’s head here. Could this be the shape of things to come?
*Dumbledore helpfully suggests Harry could let Kreacher work for him. So Dumbledore gets another house elf out of the bargain. Always gets something out of the deal, does Dumbledore.
*Hagrid would be delighted to have Buckbeak live with him. I’m sure he’s learned his lesson about being recklessly stupid with animals. That is, he’s learned that if other people are recklessly stupid enough to get bitten by them, it’s not his fault.
*The Ministry would never guess Buckbeak is the same hippogriff they once sentenced to death why, exactly? I would think it would be obvious to anyone. Do all hippogriffs look alike to them? Speciests.
*Harry finds his invisibility cloak under the bed. Dude, what did he do in that room in two weeks?
*Since this is the last time Dumbledore will be speaking with the Dursleys, he takes the opportunity to make a big ridiculous speech about how their treating Harry badly was an affront to him. I think he waits until after Kreacher’s gone to do this because Kreacher would have totally called him on the hypocrisy.
*He also zings the Dursleys on their horrible upbringing of Dudley. Trivia question: which of these two cousins is going to eviscerate a fellow student before year’s end?
*Dumbledore says he and Harry are now stepping out into the night to pursue that flighty temptress, adventure. Amazingly, Harry does not turn back around and remain with the Dursleys on the grounds of extreme gayness.
Designated Hero
See that guy teasing the family like a cross between the bully football player and the Mafia don intimidating witnesses? That’s our epitome of goodness.
Informed Attributes
He’s our epitome of goodness because of how much he cared about Harry being brought up in a loving home. He cares enough to scold his abusers at least two weeks before Harry’s never going to see them again.
IITS
Blood doesn’t matter. Except that actually it’s being with family that’s protected Harry all these years. Except that his real family are the Weasleys who love him. Except that he has to live here…look, IITS, okay?
Superfluous Racking
Dumbledore’s doing this throughout the scene because he’s such a badass with his wand and look at how scared the Dursleys are.
Final score: 4
p.s. I feel funny about using this mood. I almost feel like it should be retired in honor of
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif){kind=small}
potterstinks
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 05:28 pm (UTC)Dude, MASCULINITY. It's all about Gryffindor Testosterone and I promise, if the books were from Draco's POV, we would have a long passage about how he weeps when Snape tells him he will have scars all over from Harry's charming attack. Because he's vain and evil. And then Snape would share the secrets of disgustingly non-macho charms that will conceal them. OMG SO UNMANLY THEY ALMOST DESERVE DEATH! And they're short, too. All the more reason to hate them.
Unlike, say, crass, Muggle ME, who would be wondering if I could pay off my student loans. This is why money should stay with money.
Hahah, I know. This is what makes us Evil and Vulgar, too, as opposed to Classy and Aristocratic. We would use our money instead of heroically saving it for nobody's sake. Harry must employ half of London's goblin population with his savings by now. He's such a working-class misfit!
So. Harry’s a slave-owner now.
You just know that Mr and Mrs Harry and Ginny Potter would have a house full of slaves. They would be nice to them, of course, in that great condescending way they have. And conveniently avoid all discussions with Hermione who wouldn't protest too much once she is married to Ron because truest of all are family values and Gryffindor bonding. And it would be different, because evil people like Malfoys and every Black except Sirius (who treated Kreacher with the outmost respect, I must say) shouldn't have slaves since they are mean to them. Good people, on the other hand, should be allowed to. And how can Ginny be expected to work AND take care of her man at the same time? Huh? She needs a
illegal immigrant womanhouse-elf to help her be the PERFECT FEMALE OMG!And I don't even have any words for how annoying Dumbledore is in this chapter. Oh, Jo, you're so difficult to love. Kinda like your "good" guys, in a way. Except I still like Dumbledore better.
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 08:08 pm (UTC)Don't wanna get fat like your mom, Ginny, then Harry'll have no option but to cheat on your flabby ass. Yet you can't deny your man babies, and asap, lest he leave you for a 'natural' woman. Yup, it's time to borrow some houselves.
Because he's vain and evil.
True. Real men are hale and hearty, bad guys are ugly and yet vaguely effeminate. (And have no/rarely mentioned female partners...
They've come for our children!1!!)no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 09:18 pm (UTC)bad guys are ugly and yet vaguely effeminate
It's called layered and possibly subtle. Duh. It's not spelled out, yet always present, this terribly dangerous unspeakable crime of the female nature!
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 09:45 pm (UTC)Somehow I think the legions of fangirls who ooh & aah to finely-executed drawings of a heavily-scarred, tattooed, whip-wielding, leather-clad Dom!Snape might disagree – they're picking the disfigured fella for shallow, lustful reasons!
Yet I suspect your aforementioned "terribly dangerous unspeakable crime of the female nature" may also have something to do with the Byronification of Severus Snape*. They can't find him "sexy" until they butch him up a bit. Poor Severus – whether he's a spindly, sniveling Potions Geek or a ferocious, powerful Death-Eating spy, the fucker just can't win!
*This also happens to Draco, to a lesser extent. Need I mention leather trousers?
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 10:40 pm (UTC)Didn't you know that unless Snape is a hardcore Dom/highly experienced from his exciting life as a Death Eater Sex Machine rather than indifferent/actively avoidant of sexual activity he is OOC and must be mocked?
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 05:56 pm (UTC)Rowling's probably going to let me down again and reveal that this was her idea of funny, though.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 02:48 am (UTC)That would be my bet.
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 07:00 pm (UTC)See "the Wizarding World is a warrior culture" arguments; compare the cult of Prussian dueling scars.
*"It would have been better manners to drink it, you know." Fuck you Dumbledore. Seriously. Fuck you with your own dead black hand. *pushes Ginny out the window because she would think this was hilarious.*
Um, the last time a Dursley received something edible from a wizard it turned out to be a Ton-Tongue Toffee, and Dudley nearly choked to death. Can't say I blame them for giving the mead a pass.
Also, I'd help you drop Ginny out that window, but she'd probably do Neville one better by bouncing right back up and sticking her tongue out at us. And then hitting us with that Bat-Bogey Hex, because she's so gosh-darn sassy.
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 07:59 pm (UTC)My thoughts exactly. Not to mention his pain that time was apparently his fault for being too greedy, and now this time they're being punished for not being greedy enough.
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 09:07 pm (UTC)And wouldn't that just show us! Can't ever one-up The Other Chosen One.
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 07:06 pm (UTC)Have you perchance heard of the old adage "don't accept drinks from strange men"?
No love,
Me
his name is Señor Draco.
Now I've got this image of Draco dozing outside a tavern, a sombrero drawn over his face. Think the designated Mexicans in Lucky Luke.
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 09:03 pm (UTC)There's nothing wrong with being proactive!
*pushes Ginny out the window because she would think this was hilarious.*
YAY!
more tomorrow - ooh, april fools! must upload my pro-life and h/g icons...
Date: 2006-03-31 09:43 pm (UTC)Men are always slobs. Because it's women's/slave's jobs to clean for them. If they're lucky, we'll cluck at their endearingly mucky natures and blow their noses on our handkerchiefs.
Some are going so far as to call Harry Potter “The Chosen One” because being wizards we don’t know that’s Keanu Reeves.
He really has matured this year. From heretic to Christ himself.
The Ministry has come up with tons of new security for Hogwarts. They do not know a man is coming to destroy their petty plans for protection. His house is Slytherin and his name is Señor Draco.
LOL! Of course, if they really want to guarantee safety, they could always fire Hagrid and Dumbledore. Oh, wait, then the terrorists win.
Dear Harry, if it is convenient to you… Oh man, Albus is laying it on thick. Like he cares if it’s convenient to anyone.
Guess how surprised I was to note the next sentence is him mentioning that he wants something.
Um, I beg to differ. Harry lives right upstairs.
But his heart is pure and pristine.
So if Sirius hadn’t left a will Kreacher would have gone to Bellatrix? That was pretty stupid on the Order’s part, wasn’t it? Or is Dumbledore lying because he wants Harry to have Kreacher for some reason?
I guess it doesn't matter. What Dumbledore wants, Dumbledore gets, laws or no. (It's why he loves Harry so much, they have that in common.) Or has he puts: "We shall have to think of some other means of keeping him from his rightful mistress."
So. Harry’s a slave-owner now. I’m sure Hermione will have something to say about that. After two books of non-stop SPEW it’s sure to just come to a head in this book.
I love that Harry finds the idea 'repugnant' because he's owning the creature that betrayed Sirius, rather than because he owns another living being. (Iirc, later Harry's described as 'rarely felt more in sympathy with
SPEW.' Surely that's supposed to read 'rare felt sympathy'?)
And don't worry about Hermione, she has the miraculous power to overcome her objections to behaviour when it's her friends that are acting up. They must endow you with this when you get your Gryffindor tie. Plus she has no time for SPEW now it's all about landing a man.
More gold for Harry—phew! The world needs more heirs to fortunes who actually deserve it.
Harry's the Paris Hilton of the WW. Except at least she actually spends her's.
By the way, Lupin’s been reduced to donating pints of blood for money, but I’m sure he’d want Sirius’ money to go to you.
LOL. But Lupin's a good guy, so naturally he would put Harry's getting extra riches above his own welfare. All good guys love Harry before themselves, as with any religion. (Don't bring it up, or JKR will hit us over the head with 'Harry so generous' anvils like in GoF!)
Also you don't get money for donating blood in the UK! :(
Sirius’ will was discovered. Could that sound more fake? How long did it take you to write that will before you discovered it, Big D? And he left Harry everything, you say?
Seriously. Sirius, the caricature of rebellion managed to fill in a will? Officially and everything? Through some kind of pansy-assed lawyer? (I bet it was just written on a cigarette paper.)
The Ministry would never guess Buckbeak is the same hippogriff they once sentenced to death why, exactly?
I must say, I have no idea what the current conspiracy theory about this is/was (something to do with H/Hr having Buckbeak as their symbol, so JKR chosing to spite them? Would JKR really be capable of such subtlety?...) but I don't get the point of including Buckbeak in this book, let alone changing his name.
Anyway, what if the Slytherins see him? Is Hagrid still teaching lessons with hippogryffs?
Re: more tomorrow - ooh, april fools! must upload my pro-life and h/g icons...
Date: 2006-03-31 10:28 pm (UTC)Bwahaha!
SIRIUS: *smoking, which is cool when he does it and it doesn't even stain his fingers because his skin is like marble, 'cept it's rugged and manly marble* "Fuck everything! Omg! Fuck wills! Fuck this life! Fuck the afterlife! I just want... um, well, Jo what IS it that I want? Oh, right - JUSTICE! Fuck justice!"
REMUS: *angstily and woefully* "Sirius, since we are Teh Tragic Heroes, maybe you should write that will after all. You've got a lot of shiny things..."
SIRIUS: "You want my house? In this world without any concept whatsoever about male friendship I suppose you'd be my wife or some shit. And if I gave you money you could buy some NEW FRIGGING CLOTHES. Whatever. Fuck you."
REMUS: *woefully and angstily* "Oh no, I could never make any sort of claim on anything that is good and pure, my friend. For I am the only werewolf in the village. I am DOOMED to lead a lonely and tragic life, untouched by human kindness and the bonds of friendship."
SIRIUS: *scribbling something on the back of something Cool* "Okay then, I give everything to Harry. You self-pitying pansy."
REMUS: *angstily, woefully AND bitterly because doesn't he just have it all?* "A good decision, Sirius. *carves I DON'T DESERVE ANYTHING BETTER into his arm, to the delight of all fangirls and Tonks* Now I must leave you, and go tear my soul apart, for it's a full moon and you know I tend to be a little sloppy with my preventive potions."
SIRIUS: "Whatever. Fuck off."
no subject
Date: 2006-03-31 10:21 pm (UTC)Too right. I got in a heated fury about it back in the day (http://community.livejournal.com/deathtocapslock/2361.html?thread=39225#t39225), and my opinion of Dumbles, S.P.E.W. and this chapter in general hasn't changed one iota.
Sadly, I find myself getting my hopes up that the Dursleys will get a chance to show Harry how little they care that Dumbledore has died next year, but presumably Ron and Hermione will descend on their house and move in to bully them for weeks in his place. This will go over with all the readers who haven’t figured out they themselves are Muggles yet.
Or worse yet, R & H will bully each other as histrionically as possible while making a complete wreck of the Dursleys' house. Poor Petunia. :(
By the way, Lupin’s been reduced to donating pints of blood for money, but I’m sure he’d want Sirius’ money to go to you.
Oh man – totally! Lupin is a Token Dark Creature (http://community.livejournal.com/deathtocapslock/2361.html?thread=40505#t40505), who should be thankful for whatever crumbs he gets from the Order and is completely understanding when those crumbs don't come his way.
As for Dumbles forging Sirius' will – Ooooo, you're making me look forward to Book 7 again. Quit it,
Petunia shrieks. Nothing this filthy has entered her house in living memory. Um, I beg to differ. Harry lives right upstairs.
Poor Petunia. :(
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 02:19 am (UTC)Exactly. I once saw the phrase "self-hating little giggle" to describe someone's flippant account of an actually rather degrading sexual incident. That's pretty much what I hear, too, when Lupin recites the signs of a werewolf -- "one, he's sitting on my chair" -- in response to James' and Sirius' joshing (Hey wolf boy, how'd you like the werewolf question, eh? Eh? Nudge nudge?). Another werewolf might have told them where to stick their patronage, but as we all know, JKR can't imagine any other reaction than humble gratitude when high-status Gryffindors give someone their halfway positive attention.
Good point, too, about Dumbledore setting a bad example for Harry with his bullying of the Dursleys. DD quite often indulges in more or less subtle dissing of authority figures in front of Harry, because Harry is totally mature and analytical enough to understand DD's perspective. It's not like he already has a problem with authority or anything. Also, god forbid he should just put the Dursleys behind him now that he's almost of age and on the verge of moving out. Every little scrap of revenge after the fact helps.
-L
Hello Anonymous L!
Date: 2006-04-03 07:46 pm (UTC)It's a schtick that's painfully obvious to a more intelligent outside observer. But kids who are socially inexperienced (like Harry – and perhaps many younger readers of the books) always fall for it.
Dumbledore is the Cool Adult who takes the kids' side against the Uncool Adults. He gains their admiration & trust by both catering to their more juvenile desires (notice Dumbles always has candy about, and reference is often made to his sweet tooth? The underlying assumption is: kids like candy, Dumbles likes candy, so if A=B and B=C, A must therefore =C and kids like Dumbles!) and by showing blatant displays of power over Uncool Adults in front of kids.
The problem is that Cool Adults don't always have the kids' best interests at heart, and after 6 books JKR has NOT convinced me that Dumbledore actually gives a shit about Harry as a person. Harry is catered to by Dumbles insomuch as he's useful; when he questions or displeases Dumbledore (as he does in HPB), the tone quickly changes.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 12:16 am (UTC)Nope, just the first one.
*I know I already mentioned him being a slob but…apple cores? That’s gross. I’ll bet there’s owl droppings all over everything too.
There is a reason that the Dursley kept Harry in closets as much as possible.
*So…does Augusta Longbottom think Neville is a friend of Harry’s because Neville pathetically talks about him all the time, or is she, like everyone else, just desperate to drop Harry’s name?
But... the Longbottom are a True Aristocratic Family, not like those vulgar Malfoys. Surely she wouldn't?
*By the way, Lupin’s been reduced to donating pints of blood for money, but I’m sure he’d want Sirius’ money to go to you.
Lupin has an highly infective illness, he shouldn't donate blood. Of course, being Lupin, he wouldn't care anyway.
*Vernon reminds us how awful he is by looking greedy at the idea of Harry being left a house.
Did the Dursley get any money for keeping and feeding Harry? And... did we see Lily's will? She died after James, so she inherited from him at least in part, and part of her state should go to her sister. Even more so if she did not make a will. Or maybe the Potters made a will and Dumbledore ate it.
*Dumbledore helpfully suggests Harry could let Kreacher work for him. So Dumbledore gets another house elf out of the bargain. Always gets something out of the deal, does Dumbledore.
He may have got a spy in his own house. Kreacher may have feigned to be forced to obey Harry.
Amazingly, Harry does not turn back around and remain with the Dursleys on the grounds of extreme gayness.
Would Harry be troubled by extreme gayness?
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 12:26 am (UTC)Nope, just the first one.
In this book.
*By the way, Lupin’s been reduced to donating pints of blood for money, but I’m sure he’d want Sirius’ money to go to you.
Lupin has an highly infective illness, he shouldn't donate blood. Of course, being Lupin, he wouldn't care anyway.
Not to worry, he's not proud of himself.
Or maybe the Potters made a will and Dumbledore ate it.
It's looking more and more like he would have drank it.
Amazingly, Harry does not turn back around and remain with the Dursleys on the grounds of extreme gayness.
Would Harry be troubled by extreme gayness?
Never. He had no one pretty like Cedric or Tom to look at at the Dursley's anyway.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 08:14 am (UTC)It's looking more and more like he would have drank it.
Mead at the Dursley, gin for Mrs. Cole at the orphanage, and the poisoned bottle of mead Ron drank from was for him... but I think he never drinks, himself. He prefers acid pops.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-07 01:58 pm (UTC)I can't be the first to say this, but it would explain a lot about the Wizarding World if its moral leader is constantly out of his mind on hard drugs.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-08 12:28 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-04-08 10:58 am (UTC)"Seen the Fizzing Whizbees, Harry?" said Ron, grabbing him and leading him over to their barrel. "And the Jelly Slugs? And the Acid Pops? Fred gave me one of those when I was seven -- it burnt a hole right through my tongue. I remember Mum walloping him with her broomstick." Ron stared broodingly into the Acid Pop box. "Reckon Fred'd take a bit of Cockroach Cluster if I told him they were peanuts?"
Really makes one wonder why anyone would eat one of those things voluntarily.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-03 08:03 pm (UTC)I picked up on this possibility as well – an alternate scenario would be that whoever actually inherited Kreacher ordered him to go along with Dumbledore's plans for the moment and pass info along.
This ties in with the fact that he's ultimately assigned to follow Draco around – and who's more concerned about Draco's welfare than anyone else? Who's tight with Dumbledore's man Severus Snape, as we saw in Chapter 2?
No sissy, Cissy. :D
no subject
Date: 2006-04-04 08:41 pm (UTC)Do you think that Narcissa is the other spy of Dumbledore in Voldemort's camp? It may explain how Dumbledore knew so well what happened of Kreachur after that he left Grimmauld Place.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-05 04:30 pm (UTC)God I hope so. Since we had the anvils in GoF about how much poor old Crouch deserved lingering insanity and death for having an elf, I suppose it'd be too much like consistency if Harry too got punished for forcing Kreacher to work for him.
Did the Dursley get any money for keeping and feeding Harry?
I'm sure that the headteacher of Hogwarts, where they eat on gold plates, couldn't possibly afford to subsidise them if James and Lily didn't leave a will.
But... the Longbottom are a True Aristocratic Family, not like those vulgar Malfoys.
LOL. So are the Weasleys, as some would point out (they're not really poor! They're more liked landed gentry, not those dirty chav/trailer trash working-class types!) and they like to make friends with the powerful, too.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-05 05:11 pm (UTC)If Kreacher knew anything of Draco's plan and was not compelled to reveal it to Harry, I dare say _Dumbledore_ has been adequately punished.
I'm sure that the headteacher of Hogwarts, where they eat on gold plates, couldn't possibly afford to subsidise them if James and Lily didn't leave a will.
That's because living as Oliver Twist gives a boy better morals than being a Pampered Prince!
And I still think that if the Potters left no wills, Petunia should have inherited part of their riches. And someone has to tell Harry that the taxes on all those inheritances will be murder.
Also: from whom did Sirius inherit? His parents died _before_ his grandparents.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 01:02 am (UTC)I sometimes wonder if JKR got the idea for her characterizations from watching The Wizard of Oz; "Only bad witches are ugly!"
*So. Harry’s a slave-owner now. I’m sure Hermione will have something to say about that. After two books of non-stop SPEW it’s sure to just come to a head in this book. Funny how it doesn’t enter Harry’s head here.
I know a lot of people get angry when someone says JKR wrote Hermione or whatever character "out of character", but her lack of reaction to Harry owning Kreacher and her complete dropping of SPEW is one of the reasons why some people think that. And guess what? It's not about shipping!
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 02:54 am (UTC)Yeah, I get that. That didn't seem OOC to me, though, because I always thought Hermione took up SPEW because she was bored and needed something to feel righteous about, and that it wouldn't last. So it doesn't surprise me that she'd get sick of it.
Somehow, though, I don't think JKR wants me to think that. I think she wants me to think Hermione was sincerely committed to SPEW--but if that's true then HBP is OOC.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 05:07 am (UTC)This sort of thing is such a huge problem with trying to figure out half of what's going on with characterization in these books. *gets headache* I'm with you on thinking that it was Hermione's current pet project. Either way it doesn't look so great for her.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-05 04:25 pm (UTC)I never thought that was OOC, myself, but then I always thought Hermione (and indeed, all the Trio) have one rule for themselves and each other; and another for those around them.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 02:53 am (UTC)*Dumbledore says he and Harry are now stepping out into the night to pursue that flighty temptress, adventure. Amazingly, Harry does not turn back around and remain with the Dursleys on the grounds of extreme gayness.
Dude, yes. Dumbledore's such a queen.
no subject
Date: 2006-10-05 11:44 am (UTC)Creamtea.
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 05:20 am (UTC)Harry, naturally, accepts his second fortune in gold with dignity by not caring at all.
Considering how many years he didn't have anything for himself, I'm always kind of shocked how willing he is to spend it all. And how little he understands that generally? People are embarrassed to have their friends have to pay for things for them.
I'll never understand why DD kept Kreacher around at all. As if it wasn't painfully obvious last book that he should have at least removed him from the house.
no subject
Date: 2006-10-05 11:45 am (UTC)Creamtea
no subject
Date: 2006-04-01 05:57 am (UTC)You know, for all the hype and going on and on about how JKR has revolutionized the fantasy genre and how she's so creative and just TEH OMG BEST EVA!!!!1!!1 you'd think she'd come up with a better phrase than "Chosen One". Honestly. I think this is where I started to lose hope in the book.
Yay library computer!!
Date: 2006-04-01 02:51 pm (UTC)One of them :(
apple cores? That’s gross.
Well, quite. Leaving papers everywhere is one thing, a couple of old shirts on the floor is okay, but food? No, you put that in a plastic bag, and take it out to the rubbish like a normal person (and we assume Petunia doesn't leave the rubbish collection until it develops little flies)
This is a world where pretty much everything can be cured, yet we’ve got all these Gryffindor men walking around with scarred faces. Don’t tell me that’s not intentional.
I've wondered before about Moody's scarred bits. I mean to say, if they can grow whole new sets of arm-bones in people, he probably doesn't have to go about with that wooden leg. I suspect it may be a bit like that tribal scarring, where people can look at a person and know exactly what they do for a living and just how unimaginably hard they are. And again, Remus's torn and woeful clothes. There must be a charm that could do that up, but no, he prefers to go around looking like he's made of old socks.
Dumbledore says Sirius’ will was discovered. Could that sound more fake? How long did it take you to write that will before you discovered it, Big D? And he left Harry everything, you say?
Good point. After all, I don't think I know anyone who's written a will (not that I know many people with much to leave) and I doubt someone as reckless and OMGBRAVE as Sirius would carefully plan out his final will and testament in the event of a tragedy.
May write more soon :)
no subject
Date: 2006-07-04 07:29 pm (UTC)Nah. Because owls don't leave droppings. They regurgitate owl pellets. That's an inaccuracy that irritates me all to pieces, because some dev editor/fact checker should have caught it.
Fun analysis! I'm enjoying reading it from the beginning. :-)
no subject
Date: 2006-07-04 07:50 pm (UTC)Glad you're enjoying the recaps!